In my first post here, I mentioned Project Wonderful. If you look on the right side of this page, you'll see one Project Wonderful ad, so you can see I'm still using their service. There's a lot more to say about it than that brief earlier mention, however, so I wanted to share my good and not-so-great experiences.
- I think I've sold a book...
- I think I've sold at least one book as a result of advertising through Project Wonderful. However, most of my sales are on Amazon and tracking sales there is tricky at best. It would be easier if I could just use Amazon affiliate links through Project Wonderful, since I could then assign a tracking code just for Project Wonderful ads, but this is prohibited by Amazon. Despite the many good things that Amazon has done for indie writers, enabling us to track sources of sales is not one of them (other than via affiliate links on our sites, which—at least in my experience—is not where most sales come from).
- I've gained new mailing list subscribers.
- This was the inspiration for this blog post and thus its title. I use Mailchimp for my newsletter... chimp, ape, get it? OK, not the greatest. Anyway, Project Wonderful has helped me get new subscribers. My list is still very small, but those that I've picked up by way of a promotion on Project Wonderful are good subscribers—they open my messages! Others on my list are not so interested and often don't open my newsletters–or if they do, they're blocking my awareness of it (which I don't disagree with, even if I like to see the stats).
- I've earned a little money by hosting ads.
- I've never accumulated enough to withdraw money, but I haven't really intended to do that either. What money I do bring in from other advertisers ends up going back out to promote my books (and other things) on other sites. I suspect this is not uncommon for Project Wonderful users, especially those on the low-earning end. Sites that bring in solid revenue every day already have substantial traffic and presumably don't need to cycle funds back into advertising.
- I can use it "for free" if I want to.
- I've deposited I think a total of $5 there, but there are many sites in their network where you can advertise for free (depending on current bidding). Most of the ads I run are bid at $0/day. You can also do as I've done, running my own ad blocks for other advertisers and then using revenue from that to pay for my ads to show up elsewhere.
- The ad network seems heavily oriented around comics.
- It seems difficult to find useful places to advertise books, and part of this is an apparently strong bias in the ad network toward Web comics. By "bias" I don't mean that Project Wonderful is doing that intentionally, it just seems to have developed that way. If I search broadly (i.e., all banner sizes, etc.) on the two categories related to comics, I get thousands of results. If I search on two categories related to books, I get a few hundred. I'd love to see more diversity in the network for more variety in relevant ad placement options.
- The site itself is buggy.
- There are enough flaws in the Project Wonderful site that I have a hard time trusting the accuracy of anything, which keeps me from depositing more funds for ads rather than just re-using ad revenue I earn. Even seemingly-simple things like correctly ordering things numerically, such as sorting current ads by impression count, have been broken for as long as I can remember.
- They regularly "delist" my ad blocks.
- Supposedly to protect advertisers (who can't manage this themselves?), they periodically disable "underperforming" ad blocks. This means if you run ads on your site and your site doesn't meet their performance criteria (which, admittedly, are fairly generous), they "delist" your ads so that you can't accept any ads or earn anything more. You can re-enable the delisted ad blocks, as I did today for the ad block shown here, but that's a hassle. If your site traffic is steady, this might be added incentive to strive for an overall traffic boost. If your site traffic is spiky, however, you might have your ad block delisted just before a spike and that exposure would go to waste, at least in terms of statistics that other advertisers see when evaluating your site. I think they should drop this and rely on advertisers managing their own performance requirements.
Have you tried using Project Wonderful to promote your books? You're welcome to share your results in the comments.